Notes on Determining Priority Among Competing Mortgages in Ghana and Africa

Introduction

The determination of priority among competing mortgages is a crucial aspect of property law. It ensures clarity and fairness in resolving disputes involving multiple claims on a property. In Ghana and across Africa, the priority of mortgages is influenced by various legal, regulatory, and customary frameworks. The rules governing these priorities are essential for protecting the interests of mortgagees (lenders) and mortgagees (borrowers) and ensuring a robust real estate market.

Legal Framework in Ghana

1. Foundational Laws:
• The Mortgages Act, 1972 (NRCD 96) is the primary legislation governing mortgages in Ghana.
• Related statutes include the Land Title Registration Act, 1986 (PNDCL 152) and the Lands Commission Act, 2008 (Act 767).
2. Priority Determination:
• Date of Registration: The priority of competing mortgages is primarily determined by the order of their registration with the Lands Commission.
• First in Time, First in Right: Under Ghanaian law, the first registered mortgage takes precedence over subsequent mortgages.
• Legal vs. Equitable Mortgages:
• A legal mortgage, being formally registered, has priority over an equitable mortgage, which may arise from an unregistered agreement.
3. Effect of Non-Registration:
• Unregistered mortgages are not enforceable against third parties, including subsequent mortgagees who register their interests.
• This principle is upheld to promote transparency and order in the mortgage market.

Legal Framework in Africa

1. Common law jurisdictions:
• Countries like Ghana, Nigeria, and Kenya follow the common law principle of "priority by registration."
• A mortgage becomes enforceable and gains priority only upon registration with the appropriate land registry.
2. Civil law jurisdictions:
• Francophone African countries influenced by the Napoleonic Code may prioritize mortgages based on the date of the mortgage agreement, even if unregistered.
• This approach differs significantly from common law systems.
3. Customary Land Tenure:
• In countries like Ghana, Uganda, and Zambia, customary land tenure systems often coexist with statutory laws.
• Competing claims on customary lands may lack formal registration, complicating the determination of priority.

Key Factors in Determining Mortgage Priority

1. Registration:
• The most critical factor in Ghana and most African countries.
• Timely and accurate registration at the Lands Commission or equivalent authority is essential.
2. Notice:
• Actual or constructive notice of an existing mortgage may affect the priority of subsequent mortgages.
• A lender with knowledge of an earlier mortgage may be deemed to have accepted a subordinate position.
3. Subordination Agreements:
• Parties may enter into agreements specifying the order of priority among competing mortgages.
4. Fraud and Forgery:
• Fraudulent registrations can undermine the integrity of the priority system.
• Legal frameworks often include provisions to address disputes arising from fraud.
5. Court Judgments:
• In cases of disputes, courts play a pivotal role in interpreting laws and determining priority.

Challenges in Determining Priority

1. Double Registration:
• Instances of double or multiple registrations for the same property create confusion and disputes.
2. Unclear Land Titles:
• Lack of proper land documentation and title verification affects the priority determination process.
3. Customary and statutory conflicts:
• In areas governed by customary tenure, unregistered mortgages may compete with registered ones, leading to legal uncertainties.
4. Administrative Inefficiencies:
• Delays and errors in the registration process weaken the system of determining mortgage priority.

Solutions and Emerging Trends

1. Digitization of Land Records:
• Ghana and countries like Rwanda and Kenya are implementing digital systems to improve the efficiency and reliability of land and mortgage registration.
2. Harmonization of Laws:
• Efforts are underway to align customary and statutory laws to reduce conflicts and ensure clarity in mortgage transactions.
3. Public Awareness:
• Educating stakeholders about the importance of timely registration and proper documentation is essential for minimizing disputes.
4. Legal Reforms:
• Strengthening legal provisions to address issues like double registration and fraud is vital for a robust mortgage system.
5. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR):
• ADR mechanisms can help resolve disputes quickly and reduce the burden on courts.

Conclusion

Determining priority among competing mortgages is fundamental to maintaining order and fairness in the property market in Ghana and Africa. While challenges such as registration inefficiencies and customary land tenure complexities persist, progress is being made through digitization, legal reforms, and public education. A reliable and transparent priority system is essential for attracting investment, ensuring creditor confidence, and fostering sustainable development in the real estate sector.

Meet the Author

View Profile

---

Team Estimate

Banker

follow me