It's a new season but the same old story for Manchester United and Erik ten Hag, as the Dutchman finds his future being openly speculated about just three games into the campaign.

Sunday's 3-0 defeat at home to Liverpool—a Liverpool managed by their own Dutchman who has settled into Anfield life very smoothly in Arne Slot—has taken us right back to where we were for much of 2023-24, with many people doubting whether Ten Hag really has what it takes to succeed at Old Trafford.

One of his long-term critics, Jamie Carragher, said he'd be "surprised" if Ten Hag sees out the season at United after being given a stay of execution in the summer, but does the Mirror Football team share that view? Here's what they think: