Types of Mortgages: Equitable Mortgage

An equitable mortgage is a type of mortgage where the borrower (mortgagor) pledges property as security for a loan without transferring the legal title to the lender (mortgagee). Unlike a legal mortgage, an equitable mortgage relies on an agreement or conduct to create a security interest, making it more flexible but less secure for lenders. In Ghana and Africa, equitable mortgages play a significant role in providing access to credit, especially in cases where borrowers cannot meet the formal requirements of a legal mortgage.

Definition of Equitable Mortgage

An equitable mortgage arises when a borrower deposits property title deeds or other documents of ownership with a lender as collateral for a loan, accompanied by an agreement to create a security interest in the property.

• No Legal Title Transfer: The borrower retains ownership of the property.
• Created by Agreement: Often established through a simple written agreement or even oral consent.
• Security Interest: The lender gains an interest in the property that can be enforced in equity, not law.

Characteristics of Equitable Mortgages

1. Lack of Formality
• Equitable mortgages do not require formalities like registration or the execution of a deed, making them quicker to create.
2. Retention of Title
• Borrowers retain legal ownership of the property, and lenders hold a beneficial interest.
3. Security through Possession
• The lender typically holds title deeds or other property-related documents as evidence of the mortgage.
4. Enforcement in Equity
• Lenders can enforce their rights in equity, usually through the courts, to recover debts if the borrower defaults.

Creation of Equitable Mortgages

1. Deposit of Title Deeds
• Borrowers deposit title deeds with the lender as security for the loan.
• In Ghana and many African countries, this method is commonly used when borrowers lack access to formal documentation.
2. Written or Verbal Agreement
• An agreement between the lender and borrower may establish an equitable mortgage, even in the absence of a formal mortgage deed.
3. Loan Advances Against Property
• Lenders may advance loans based on the borrower’s pledge of ownership documents.

Advantages of Equitable Mortgages

1. Speed and Simplicity
• Easier and faster to create compared to legal mortgages, as they involve fewer formalities.
2. Flexibility
• Suitable for borrowers who lack the resources or time to complete the rigorous requirements of legal mortgages.
3. Cost-Effectiveness
• No registration fees or legal costs are required for establishing an equitable mortgage.
4. Access to Credit
• Offers an avenue for credit access to individuals who may not qualify for a legal mortgage.

Disadvantages of Equitable Mortgages

1. Weaker Security for Lenders
• The lender’s rights are limited compared to a legal mortgage, as the borrower retains legal title.
2. Difficulty in Enforcement
• Lenders must rely on equitable remedies, which can be time-consuming and uncertain.
3. Risk of Fraud
• Borrowers may pledge the same property to multiple lenders without proper documentation.
4. Lack of Public Notice
• Since equitable mortgages are not registered, other creditors may not be aware of the lender’s interest in the property.

Equitable Mortgages in Ghana

In Ghana, equitable mortgages are recognized under the Land Act, 2020 (Act 1036) and are widely used in informal financial transactions or when borrowers face difficulties registering a legal mortgage.

Common Practices:

1. Deposit of Title Deeds: Borrowers deposit property documents with banks or informal lenders to secure loans.
2. Oral Agreements: In rural areas, verbal agreements and customary practices often govern equitable mortgages.
3. Use by Small Businesses: Equitable mortgages are popular among small and medium enterprises (SMEs) that cannot meet the strict requirements of legal mortgages.

Legal Framework:

While the Land Act recognizes equitable mortgages, it emphasizes the need for clear agreements to avoid disputes and fraud. Courts in Ghana enforce equitable mortgages where the borrower’s intent to create a security interest is evident.

Equitable Mortgages in Africa

Across Africa, equitable mortgages serve as a practical alternative to legal mortgages, especially in countries with complex land tenure systems or underdeveloped financial infrastructure.

Examples:

1. Kenya: banks and microfinance institutions frequently accept deposits of title deeds as collateral for loans.
2. Nigeria: Equitable mortgages are common in informal lending where borrowers use property documents to secure loans.
3. South Africa: Equitable mortgages are less prevalent due to the availability of robust legal mortgage frameworks.

Challenges:

1. Informal Land Tenure: In many African countries, unclear land ownership makes it difficult to establish equitable mortgages.
2. Enforcement Issues: Lenders face significant hurdles enforcing equitable mortgages in courts due to legal and procedural complexities.

Enforcement of Equitable Mortgages

1. Court Proceedings
• Lenders must seek court intervention to enforce their rights, such as foreclosing on the property or compelling repayment.
2. Sale of Property
• Courts may authorize the sale of the property to recover the lender’s money.
3. Equity Principles
• Courts apply equitable principles, ensuring fairness in enforcement while protecting the borrower’s rights.

Comparison with Legal Mortgages

Conclusion

Equitable mortgages provide a flexible and accessible means of securing loans, particularly for individuals and businesses unable to meet the stringent requirements of legal mortgages. In Ghana and Africa, they address critical financing gaps but require robust legal frameworks and public awareness to minimize risks. Governments and financial institutions can enhance their utility by simplifying land tenure systems and educating borrowers on their obligations and rights.

Meet the Author

View Profile

---

Emmanuel Amoabeng Gyebi

Accountant

follow me