On a dark February night in 1864, history was made off the coast of Charleston when the Confederate submarine HL Hunley became the first underwater vessel to successfully sink an enemy ship in combat. But this groundbreaking achievement came with a devastating cost that would remain shrouded in mystery for over a century.
The sinking of the USS Housatonic began when Union sailor Robert Fleming Jr. spotted what appeared to be a metallic log approaching his vessel. Despite raising the alarm and opening fire, it was too late – the Hunley's torpedo struck its target, sending the mighty Union warship to the bottom. This revolutionary moment in naval warfare should have been cause for Confederate celebration, but instead it became one of the Civil War's most enduring mysteries when the Hunley and its eight-man crew vanished shortly after their successful attack.
The submarine's disappearance sparked more than a century of speculation and numerous failed recovery attempts. It wasn't until 1995 that the wreck was finally discovered, and another five years passed before it was carefully raised from its resting place. But rather than providing clear answers, the recovery only deepened the mystery.
What puzzled investigators most was the condition of the crew's remains. In typical maritime disasters, bodies are found clustered around exit points as crew members desperately try to escape. But inside the Hunley, each crew member's remains were found precisely at their duty stations, as if they had calmly accepted their fate – a scenario that defied explanation given human survival instincts.
The Hunley itself was a marvel of desperate innovation. Faced with a crushing Union naval blockade, the Confederacy turned to Horace Lawson Hunley and his partners to develop an underwater weapon. The result was surprisingly basic: a hand-cranked vessel powered by seven men turning a propeller shaft while an eighth man steered. Operating in the cramped interior where men couldn't even sit upright, the crew could achieve speeds of about four knots – roughly walking pace.
The submarine's development was marked by tragedy even before its famous mission. It sank twice during testing, claiming the lives of 13 men, including Hunley himself. Yet the Confederacy's desperate need to break the Union blockade meant the project continued despite these losses.
The discovery of crucial evidence in 2013 finally offered a compelling theory about the crew's fate. When researchers examined the Hunley's torpedo spar – the long pole used to ram explosives into enemy ships – they found something unexpected: fragments of the copper torpedo casing. This discovery suggested that the weapon had detonated while still attached to the Hunley, placing the submarine just 16 feet from the explosion rather than the intended 100 feet.
This revelation led scientists to propose that the crew was killed or incapacitated by the blast wave from their own weapon. When explosives detonate underwater, they create a powerful pressure wave that can pass through solid objects, including submarine hulls and human bodies. The effect on the human body, particularly the lungs and brain, can be catastrophic. A 2017 study using scale models suggested the crew had a 95% chance of suffering severe pulmonary trauma and an 84% chance of immediate death.
Yet one detail continues to challenge this theory. Shortly after the attack, witnesses from both Union and Confederate forces reported seeing a blue signal light on the water – the predetermined signal that the Hunley would use to announce mission success. If the crew was killed or incapacitated by the blast, who lit the signal? This detail has led some historians to question whether the blast wave theory fully explains the crew's fate.
Perhaps the most poignant epilogue to the Hunley story comes from a personal artifact found among the wreckage. Captain George Dixon, the submarine's final commander, carried a $20 gold coin that had reportedly saved his life at the Battle of Shiloh by deflecting a bullet. When archaeologists recovered Dixon's remains, they found the coin, bent from impact, inscribed with the words "Shiloh April 6th 1862 My life preserver G.E.D." – confirming a story that had been passed down through generations of his family.
In 2004, 140 years after their final mission, the crew of the Hunley were finally laid to rest in Charleston's Magnolia Cemetery. Tens of thousands attended the funeral, marking it as the last burial of the American Civil War. While the exact circumstances of their deaths may remain debated, their pioneering achievement in naval warfare is undisputed.
The HL Hunley's story represents more than just a military milestone – it's a testament to human ingenuity in times of desperation and a reminder of war's terrible cost. Though modern submarines bear little resemblance to the crude hand-cranked vessel that made history that February night, every successful submarine attack in the centuries since traces its lineage to those eight brave men who ventured into the dark waters off Charleston, never to return.
blogpay
Total Comments: 0